This is my second pair. Bought to replace my first pair since they were on sale, but the first pair are still rocking, as you can see in the pictures. I'm breaking in the new pair as back-ups. They were comfortable since the day I first put them on, and become even more comfortable with time. My feet never hurt, or get wet in them. The toe box is nice and wide, yet my feet feel secure in them. The leather is super tough and the outsole rubber very durable. I really like the look too. I see other people having quality issues with them, but my first pair are still in great shape after 2+ years, wearing 48 hours a week as an electrician. I think it's important to get the size that fits you properly to minimize stress on the materials. Anyways, I'll keep buying this boot as long as they're still making them, and the quality stays the same.